Mechanisms of subclinical sadism
Publication Date
July 19, 2023
Creator
Abstract
Background: Individual differences are important predictors of behaviour, attitudes, and outcomes. ‘Dark personalities’ are socially aversive, yet non-pathological personality traits found within the general population. They can adapt, flourish, and act within socially acceptable boundaries within society, but are associated with antagonistic and harmful behaviour. Subclinical Sadism encompasses a unique element that justifies its inclusion in the dark personality cluster – its intrinsic pleasure of another’s suffering.
Aims: This thesis aimed to integrate and synthesise existing research on the relationship between sadistic traits and aggressive behaviour; examine factors (temperamental traits) that predispose an individual to developing sadistic traits; investigate potential underlying mechanisms of sadism (emotional processing); consider what factors (excitation transfer) might increase sadistic traits; and explore lifestyle mechanisms (sensational interests) that might contribute to everyday sadism.
Methods: A psychometric critique was completed to evaluate the Varieties of Sadistic Tendencies (VAST; Paulhus & Jones, 2015) assessment, to understand if this was a valid and reliable measure of sadism to undertake the empirical research. A systematic review and meta-analysis were completed to evaluate the relationship between sadism and aggression within the general population. The first empirical study employed a cross-sectional design to examine the relationship between dark personality traits, physiological self-regulatory systems (Reinforcement Sensitivity Theory; Gray, 1972), and emotional responses to audio visual stimuli. The second empirical study employed a cross-sectional design to examine the relationship between sadism and sensational interests, and an experimental design to explore the effects of Excitation Transfer (Zillman, 1971).
Results: A meta-analysis using 57 effect sizes from 48 studies revealed a pooled correlation coefficient of .35 (95% CI = 0.29, 0.40) between sadism and aggression. The VAST was evaluated as a robust psychometric measure and deemed appropriate to undertake the empirical research. In empirical study one, bootstrapped correlational analyses found a negative correlation between sadism and BIS-Anxiety and FFFS-Fear, and a positive correlation with BAS-Drive. Correlational analyses found a positive correlation between sadism and experiencing enjoyment in response to violent stimuli. In empirical study two, a bootstrapped hierarchical multiple regression found that up to 26% of the variance in sadism could be predicted from sensational interests. Bootstrapped paired-samples t-tests found no significant increases in sadism or sensational interest scores, in the experimental condition designed to increase physiological arousal.
Conclusions: The results from the systematic review conclude that sadism is important in understanding a range of aggressive behaviours that occur in the general population. Findings within empirical study one, suggest that there may be temperamental predispositions to developing sadistic traits; according to RST, sadism could be understood as a high-approach low-avoidance temperamental trait. Findings also support preliminary evidence of aberrations in the emotional processing of individuals with increased sadistic traits. Findings within empirical study two suggest that sensational interests contribute to the profile of individuals with elevated sadistic traits. The influence of excitation transfer on sadism requires further exploration. This thesis concludes that in order to develop interventions aimed at reducing the risk of harmful behaviour, further research on subclinical sadism is warranted.
Item Type
ethesis
Thesis Type
DForenPsy
Supervisors
Subjects (LC)
Associated Schools / Departments
School of Medicine
eprints ID
73047
UoN Repository URI
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
LEAH THOMAS - FINAL UNMARKED COPY - RESEARCH THESIS (AFTER CORRECTIONS).pdf
Type
Full-text
Description
Examined
Size
3.59 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
36dcd75a973296a742848be7abf0d10b