Fidelity and adherence in self-management interventions for an ageing population
Publication Date
July 31, 2026
Creator
Abstract
Background: Living longer has made ageing well a health and research priority and key global challenge for policy makers, with a national and international focus on self-management interventions. Conducting research in this area has many challenges. These include population level benefits, modelling consistent interventions, as well as access to adequate frameworks and tools to measure effectiveness, adherence and implementation; so further insights are needed. In this thesis two self-management intervention trials (Lifestyle Matters and Journeying through Dementia) and one feasibility study (Journeying through Dementia) are presented. The interventions are designed to support independence, increase self-efficacy and improve resilience to age well in the community.
Aim: To explore issues of fidelity, adherence, and adaptation in the implementation of complex self-management interventions for older adults at risk of age-related decline, including people living with early-stage dementia within the context of clinical trials.
Methods: Three studies were evaluated for this thesis, consisting of two multi-centre pragmatic parallel group randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and one single site feasibility study. A mixed methods process evaluation was conducted in both trials in line with Medical Research Council (MRC) guidance on the development and evaluation of complex interventions. This included fidelity assessment using an intervention fidelity framework and an embedded qualitative study consisting of semi structured interviews with participants, supporters, facilitators and supervisors. The feasibility study included a qualitative study with facilitators and participants.
Results:
Lifestyle Matters
Publication 1: Lifestyle Matters RCT of 288 randomised participants. Analysis showed no change in the SF-36 mental wellbeing dimension or quality of life at a population level. There was significant reduction in loneliness at 24 months suggesting the intervention could have influenced a reappraisal of relationships and social networks. A lack of adherence to the overall intervention (poor attendance at individual sessions of 32%) and failing to recruit those most at risk of age-related decline may have eroded receipt of benefit.
Publication 2: Fidelity assessment findings for the Lifestyle Matters trial demonstrated good fidelity to several intervention components: facilitator training and the group sessions. However, it was not possible to observe either the individual sessions or out of venue components of the intervention due to ethical and practical challenges e.g. maintaining participant confidentiality. Future research should explore methods of assessing fidelity in trials of complex community-based interventions to overcome these challenges.
Publication 3: Qualitative findings from the Lifestyle Matters trial (13 participants). Behavioural changes identified by participants were mapped onto the intervention theory; namely practising decision-making and taking the lead, sharing and enacting activities, and positively managing age-related illness and disability. Thereby demonstrating the potential of the intervention and the self-management model for this population. Those deriving most benefit had experienced a significant life event and recognised the need for lifestyle change. How to identify and recruit adults entering age-related decline to participate in trials of self-management interventions requires further exploration.
Publication 4: Qualitative findings from 13 participants on the long-term effect on health and well-being of the Lifestyle Matters intervention at 24 months post randomisation. Sustained benefits and increases in self-efficacy were reported but were overall not perceived as significantly improving health and well-being. The intervention was found to boost self-efficacy through performance accomplishment and modelling influences. Those who experienced significant life changing events appeared to get most benefit, suggesting that the intervention maybe most effective at the time when lifestyle change must be reconsidered.
Journeying through Dementia
Publication 5: Journeying through Dementia feasibility study of 10 participants. Findings suggest the intervention design and mode of delivery was acceptable although capacity to participate in the intervention was influenced by memory. Reported benefits included increased confidence and self-efficacy, engagement in new or lapsed activities and re-engagement in fun and friendships. Appropriate outcomes were not available at the time to measure all aspects of reported benefit such as social support and social networks. Identification of participants through memory services maximised recruitment.
Publication 6: Journeying through Dementia trial of 480 participants. The study found no improvement in self-reported quality of life. There were indications of improved psychological wellbeing in those who received the intervention, but other secondary outcomes selected to address other important aspects showed no differences. The quality of life (DEMQoL) scores replicated those in other trials, from which we deduced the DEMQoL may not be sensitive enough to detect changes attributed to these types of intervention. The secondary outcomes had not been validated in dementia populations but were selected due to the paucity of suitable validated measures.
Publication 7: Fidelity assessment findings from the Journeying through Dementia trial replicated those of the Lifestyle Matters intervention. There was good fidelity for the facilitator training and delivery of the group sessions components. More data were collected on the out of venue and individual session components compared to Lifestyle Matters, but using limited and inherently biased methodology (facilitator self-report only). The question remains how to assess fidelity in community-based complex interventions without impacting upon the integrity of the intervention whilst maintaining participant confidentiality.
Publication 8: Qualitative findings from 25 Participants in Journeying through Dementia. This study identified four factors that could moderate delivery and receipt of the intervention: context and environment; readiness, training, skills and competencies of the workforce; identifying meaningful participation and relationships. Benefits of the intervention were nuanced to each participant in line with the personalised approach. Mechanisms of behaviour change were influenced by a range of individual social and contextual factors. Future research should consider how best to identify and measure the multifaceted interplay of mechanisms of change in self-management interventions.
Publication 9: Reflections on experiences of Patient and Public Involvement (PPI) in dementia research through the Journeying through Dementia Trial. Involving people with lived experience of dementia improved the accessibility and relevance of the research for participants. The successful engagement of people living with early-stage dementia and their supporters was associated with staff skills and engagement techniques to scaffold meaningful involvement, recognising participants’ memory and cognitive capacity. Meaningful engagement was influenced by diminishing cognitive abilities and the resilience of the individual. Further consideration is needed in relation to the lifespan of a trial (typically 4 years +) and ongoing activities such as presentations and publications that typically occur beyond the end of the trial which can be affected by timing of conferences and administrative inefficiency.
Publication 10: A review of strategies to run a successful pragmatic trial of a self-management complex intervention for people living with early diagnosis dementia reflecting on the Journeying through Dementia Trial. Recommendations for future research include recruiting additional staff to deliver the intervention; having clear protocols in place for managing staff absences; utilising supervision to problem solve intervention delivery challenges; ensuring ring-fenced time to deliver the intervention and engage in supervision; and regular monitoring and feedback in relation to fidelity to delivery of the intervention.
Discussion: Self-management interventions have emerged as an attractive solution to policy makers seeking to address the challenges posed by an ageing population in conjunction with a resource diminished health service. However, translating this into effective, evidence-based practice requires careful consideration of how such interventions are delivered and evaluated in real-world settings. This body of work contributes to our understanding of the challenges and considerations surrounding fidelity, adherence, and adaptation in the implementation of complex self-management interventions for older adults at risk of age-related decline, including those living with early-stage dementia. It situates these issues within the broader context of intervention development and trial design drawing on the strengths of the presented studies, that of robust trial methodology, applied fidelity frameworks and multi-method process evaluations.
Evidence from the Lifestyle Matters and Journeying through Dementia trials indicates that older adults at risk of age-related decline, including those with early-stage dementia, can engage with and benefit from self-management interventions when these are appropriately supported and delivered at the right stage in life. However, these findings are drawn largely from predominantly homogeneous participant groups, which limits their wider generalisability and raises important questions about the cultural relevance, acceptability, and accessibility of such interventions for more diverse populations. Across both trials, fidelity to facilitator training and group-based components of the intervention was strong, but major challenges arose in monitoring the more flexible, individualised components due to ethical, practical, and confidentiality constraints. Poor adherence, particularly to individual sessions, combined with difficulty recruiting those most likely to benefit, likely diluted intervention effects. The selected outcome measures often lacked sensitivity to detect the nuanced, personalised changes reported qualitatively in this population. Fidelity was also shaped by contextual and workforce-related factors, including facilitator skill, supervision, and organisational pressures. Together, these findings highlight a core limitation of current fidelity methods in their design and application to complex, community-based self-management interventions for older adults, especially those at risk of age-related decline or living with early dementia.
Despite this, there remains a clear need for more targeted, adequately resourced, and effective interventions that reach those most likely to benefit and can be rigorously evaluated for implementation fidelity. Future research should therefore establish acceptable mechanisms for identifying and engaging those most likely to benefit and prioritise the development of fidelity frameworks and assessment methods that are more acceptable, unobtrusive, and both context and culturally appropriate.
Item Type
ethesis
Thesis Type
PhD
Supervisors
Subjects (LC)
Associated Schools / Departments
School of Medicine
eprints ID
83023
UoN Repository URI
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
PhD_Thesis_KSprange_28.11.25.pdf
Type
Full-text
Description
Examined
Size
8.16 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
3d8ea40eff6c435f7eafef56410cfe90